| Rank | Player | ID | Win-Loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | David Hanna | 527 | 45 - 15 |
| 2 | Jason Brand | 433 | 44 - 16 |
| 3 | Aaron Cooke | 105 | 39 - 21 |
| Bill Walborn | 325 | 39 - 21 | |
| 5 | Patrick Volk | 383 | 38 - 22 |
| Donny White | 127 | 38 - 22 | |
| 7 | Andrew Lum | 348 | 37 - 23 (tied for first-round bye) won by default |
| John Delzoppo | 341 | 37 - 23 (tied for first-round bye) won by default | |
| Simon Brown | 223 | 37 - 23 (tied for first-round bye) absent from tiebreaker | |
| 10 | Frederick Asher | 392 | 36 - 24 |
| Scott Kutheis | 332 | 36 - 24 | |
| William F Wulf II | 135 | 36 - 24 | |
| Ron Hallett Sr | 229 | 36 - 24 | |
| Kevin Myers | 501 | 36 - 24 | |
| JT Harrison | 213 | 36 - 24 | |
| 16 | Brandon Schwab | 555 | 35 - 25 |
| 17 | Dustin Ohl | 450 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker |
| Erin Ray | 448 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker | |
| Chris Compton | 552 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker | |
| Rod Winzinek | 233 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker | |
| Larry West | 518 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker | |
| Jonathan Williams | 367 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker | |
| Bobby Joseph | 528 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) lost tiebreaker | |
| Steve Kapinos | 369 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker | |
| Daniel Cotter | 232 | 34 - 26 (tied to advance) won tiebreaker |