Live from PAPA 5, and you are (virtually) there

Actually, this page isn't entirely live anymore; it's more a hodge-podge of pictures and descriptions of the weekend's events, with some sections untouched since Friday, others entirely new, and some updated. (Updated entries will be marked with an [Updated] tag, so you can search for them in your browser if you don't want to read through the whole page again.)

I realize it's kind of bad HTML form to put so much on one big page, but browsing through a big, unorganized mess will give you a sense of what PAPA 5 was like at times...

(One thing I don't want to get lost in the shuffle: my photo-op brainstorm with Kai Bateman and Williams' latest, Dirty Harry. Check it out by clicking here.)


On the floor: what it looks like

The Park Central Hotel's ballroom seems perfectly suited to a pinball tournament; here's a quick look around, complete with some running commentary from yours truly.

The view from the floor

Two views of the floor, from floor level near the podium and from the balcony that surrounds it. Folks are using the balcony as the smoking section this year (which is too bad, in my opinion, because I think it may discourage non-smokers from hanging out up there); but it's also a great place to take a break from the action on the floor and socialize with folks you haven't seen in a while, or even meet new people.

In the picture: Rick Stetta (White T-Shirt) and Neil Schatz (Green Sweatshirt).

The view from the balcony

Had I realized I had Greg and Orin looking on from the balcony as I played exactly one good game of Demolition Man in the A division bank (out of a total of 8 games, nearly all of which I screwed up one way or the other), I probably would have screwed that game up, too, but it was nice to hear some encouraging words from on high when I was done. So I'll try to return the favor tomorrow when I'm watching someone else pull out a qualifying score by really killing one of the games.

In case you are wondering who is playing in this picture. From bottom to top: Kenji Ishii is playing on Tommy, Rob Chesnavich on Demolition Man, Fred Richardson on Freddy, and Lyman Sheats on World Cup Soccer.


General commentary for Sunday afternoon

There's something to be said for being able to play competitive pinball at 3:30 in the morning, and that's exactly what the doubles competitors were doing when their play was suspended by a fire alarm as a small "contained" fire caused the evacuation of the 15th floor and yet another delay. I left just as the "B" doubles competition ended (with Rick Stetta and Neil Shatz winning over New York favorites Rob Rosenhouse and Kai Bateman), but the "A" doubles continued on, long into Sunday morning. Lyman told me later that day that he physically wasn't able to participate in the PAPA Champions division Sunday morning because it started only a couple of hours after he'd finished the doubles, and a couple of hours of sleep just wasn't going to be enough if he wanted to do well in the "A" division finals.

Can't say I blame him, since I was a wreck myself on Sunday, and I didn't even have to play any more pinball.

As it happened, Sunday was a day for the finalists in all divisions, but for the rest of us there was free play on all the pinball machines not in use for a competition; there were special one-time events (like a one-ball event on TOMMY that was so popular the payoff went over $350); and a swarm of media people there to cover the finals but more than willing to talk to non-finalists, too. I myself got a few seconds of air time on New York 1 (a local all-news cable station), although they got my name wrong.

A PAPA trophy

[Updated Tuesday night]

I'm going to get the official results from all divisions from Steve tomorrow morning, so I should have something up on this page by the end of the week at the latest. Stay tuned to the What's New page for details.

[Updated Tuesday morning]

I couldn't stay around for the end of the "A" division finals (or the Women's finals, which were running at the same time), so I missed the awards ceremony at the end of the day. But the trophy above is what the first place finalists got, and I figured that people might want a look at it. It's one of the best-looking trophies of any kind I've ever seen, much nicer than the generic trophies that are often handed out. Steve gets custom trophies made up for his leagues as well, and they, too, are very nice, and obviously pinball-related. No chance of confusing any of the PAPA 5 trophies with bowling trophies...


General commentary for Saturday afternoon

It snowed late last night and early this morning. A lot. A whole lot. And yet there are still lots of people here; in fact, being on the tournament floor you could almost forget that all the regional airports were closed this morning. (That's a good thing, because the same thing happened at PAPA 3, and back then Saturday afternoon wasn't a busy time at all. This time it seems like the blizzard hasn't kept too many people away, although I'm sure a lot of folks who planned on driving down from states on the eastern seaboard changed their minds when they looked outside this morning and saw a whole lot of white.)

The Internet mini-tournament got underway a little late, but the turnout has been fantastic so far. Not everyone has had a chance to play yet, but at least a few of the top players have been through. (In fact, Kevin Martin's top score of just over 2B was just demolished by Noel Steere's score of nearly 5.6B, almost certainly ensuring that he'll be the top qualifier.) I expect it'll be nearly as tough to qualify in the Internet mini-tournament as it will in the A Division, which shows just how good the players on the Net are. We're not quite at the point where every single top player is on the Net, but it's getting close...

[Updated Monday night]

We had hoped to run semi-finals and finals in the Internet mini-tournament, but alas it was not to be. Not if we had any hope of finishing before the doubles competitions got underway, in any case, and that was the motivation behind Steve Epstein's suggestion that we shut everything down at 6:00 PM and just take the top 4 qualifiers and call them finalists in the order in which they qualified. Naturally Noel was all for this idea, but the rest of the qualifiers agreed that it was the only thing we could do, given the cirucumstances. Next year we'll know that the RGP tournament will need its own bank of games, and that sharing with the PAPA Champions division doesn't give us enough time to allow everyone to play and run 2 levels of finals.

I apologize to everyone who didn't get a chance to play; all I can say is that we did our best and promise to do better next year. Turnout for the RGP tournament surprised everyone; I don't think anyone expected more than a couple dozen entries at most, yet over 60 people registered via email and over 40 people got to play, with nearly 50 on the list Saturday afternoon (which means that about 10 people didn't get to play).

See the PAPA-5 Internet Mini-Tournament page for the final standings.

Preliminary Results from Saturday Afternoon

Here are the results as of about 1:00 PM on Saturday. I figured it might be interesting to see how these scores stack up against the final scores; plus, it'll give the folks who aren't at the tournament an idea of what the scores are like in each division. (Please note that scores are all given in billions.)

A Division                       B Division                        C Division                   Women's Division             Doubles                                           Juniors             

Rob Chesnavich      6.807        Alexis Keldermans   3.955        Nick McKinney       3.646     Alysa Parks         3.049    Richardson/Madison                      5.041     Mike Ursic          2.173
Glenn Wilson        6.548        Jim Roberts         3.673        Jason Provost       3.025     Laurie Meidel       1.993    Dan Wilson/Dale Rice                    4.641     Joshua Sharpe       1.909
Juniet Benoit       5.850        Bill Kurtz          3.670        Chris Guilmartin    2.971     Jacki Hays          1.751    Dave Hegge/Lyman Sheats                 4.250     Victor Mendoza      1.626
Jason Werdrick      5.653        Gennady Levitan     3.462        Mare Davis          2.693     Joannie erry        1.641    Santan/Nardini                          4.172     Zachary Sharpe      1.620
Dave Stewart        4.781        Rrank Romero        3.407        Mike Field          2.688     Ellen Frankel       1.591    Rob Rosenhouse/Kai Bateman              4.107     Kevin Kulek, Jr.    1.454
Kai Bateman         4.599        Martin Keates       3.010        Dave Grossman       2.368     Kathy Kulek         1.544    Kerins/Johnson                          3.701     Mitch Kulek         1.449
Sean Grant          4.554        William Hoo         3.000        Steve Lane          2.242     Susan Jacobs        1.327    Michael Dawn/Gordon Green               3.510     David Vogel         1.256
Dae Hegge           4.535        Sam Ryan            2.872        Arthur Lee          2.236     Kathleen Beardsley  1.297    Glenn Wilson/Miller                     3.456     Chris Olsen         1.197
Lyman Sheats        4.491        Chris Farkas        2.617        Ralph Scotto        2.169     Paula Mercurio      1.289    Paul Chan/Nint Hoo                      3.454                         
Bowen Kerins        4.429        John Hurd           2.561        Cameron Silver      2.122     Sherrill Ware       1.288    Neil Shatz/Rick Stetta                  3.373                         
Rick Stetta         4.352        Parke Heller        2.440        Christopher Massa   2.097     Lisa Depierro       1.263    Parke Heller/Steve Leventhal            3.208                         
Dale Rice           4.204        Greg Dunlap         2.410        Ken Beckrich        2.089     Donna Hagen         1.151    Noel Steere/Jason Werdrick              3.003                         
George Dusichka     4.167        Sergio Johnson      2.342        Robert Kuszewski    2.070     Rosalie Holland     1.108    Gottlieb/Sharpe                         2.861                         
Frank Bona          4.160        Michael D. Dawn     2.319        Ralph Meyer         2.052     Alessandra Ferrerra 1.086    Zumoff/Kurtz                            2.814                         
Dan Wilson          4.142        Johnathan Deitch    2.263        Steve Vogel         2.005     Adena Richards      0.912    Beardsley/Fried                         2.684
Kenji Ishii         4.097        Theodore T Harris   2.250        Eddie DeCosta       1.973     Joni Levine         0.904    Miller/Farris                           2.623
Neil Shatz          4.027        Sam Field           2.247        Carl Hibshaman      1.969     Carol Haines        0.820    Alexander Abaya/Bruce Lu                2.500
Fred Richardson     3.915        Steve Leventhal     2.217        Paul Fraticelli     1.958     Patty Pisula        0.815    Stewart/Chesnavich                      2.479
John Miller         3.793        Steven Walker       2.213        Alexander Abaya     1.953     Pamel Fitgerald     0.781    Jason Provost/Dorion Whilock            2.445
Sanjay Shah         3.735        Dan Farris          2.172        Marty Debobes       1.918     Chrissy Bleine      0.767    Jim Potzel/Larry Geisler                2.247

General commentary for Friday, February 3

Lots of people showed up today; in fact, more than I expected, given that it's not even the weekend yet. Believe me, it's heartening to see so many people skip work and cut classes to play pinball... ;-)

The techs have done an amazing job so far. We've had a few major breakdowns, but most problems have been handled quickly and play doesn't seem to have been held up too long in any division. The Street Fighter 2 games are really showing their age (that, and the fact that they've all been on location for 2 years now), and at least in the A Division, SF2 is the game that's suffered from the most problems. But this afternoon it was World Cup Soccer that really held up the A Division show: the top-right gate that's supposed to open when you travel to a city (so the ball can whip around the top of the game and fly straight down the left outlane) wasn't opening. It was also nearly impossible to fix; in fact, a team of technicians had to remove the playfield from the cabinet in order to get at the gate. As you can imagine, this wasn't a quick-fix situation, and as a result it took what seemed to me to be an incredibly long time to finish my single A Division entry. (At least I was first in line to play it when it went back online.) Michael Gottlieb stood, watched, and shook his head, muttering dark things about how games really should be easier to service than that...

But that said, people definitely are entering and reentering the various divisions today, even if they do have to wait a bit before they can start playing. The practice banks are all well attended, with people especially interested in the finals machines, many of which are new to all but the Chicago contingent.

I myself got on the A Division qualifying board early Friday, and at least as of about 8PM I was still there, though rapidly sliding down toward the bottom of the board. Feel free to wish me luck, because I'm going to try to reenter once more tomorrow with the hope of getting a good enough score to hang on into the first round of the finals.

I also finally got a chance to play a few games of Dirty Harry; I guess I should reserve judgment for a while, given how little I've played it so far. On the other hand, it isJudgement Day, so allow me to present you with my snap judgement: it sucks. Haven't said that about a pin in a while, but this game didn't give me a good feeling at all. But I'll leave it to Greg to show us all how to spell its name with asterisks... ;-)

I'm planning on getting an early start tomorrow so I have time for one more go through in the A Division before helping out with the Internet mini-tournament, which will be running all morning. We have about 65 entries in the Internet tournament, which I think is pretty impressive. I'll try to post some overall stats tomorrow, even if I have to sit up by the podium (where the only working phone jack on the floor is located) and look like a complete computer geek to do so...


All commentary on this page was written by Steve Baumgarten sbb@panix.com, who was on-line live from the tournament floor.
This page is maintained by
Dave Stewart dstewart@eng.cmu.edu